Posts Tagged: editorial cartoon


4
Dec 09

Editorial cartoon: Global warming skeptics

When science becomes dogmatic, we’re all in trouble.

Leaked emails from the side that says "we’re killing the earth and we must stop now. . ." that offer to ‘encourage’ skeptics to come over to their side through blackballing and keeping their papers out of journals and such have sparked an interesting debate: When scientists abandon rigor for dogma and "do as we say or else," science becomes just another religion. That’s a bad way to go.

Most of us don’t claim to have a deep understanding of science but tend to accept reputable scientists because they use substantive data, rigorous methods and aim for reproducibility. Their theories and conclusions are reviewed by their peers and good science tends to rise above the bad. Science should be democratic.

If, however, we learn that some scientists believe that their conclusions are so important that they should not be reviewed freely, then they marginalize their influence and damage the credibility of themselves and their peers.

It doesn’t really matter if global warming is real or imaginary; a man-made disaster or natural cycle. What matters is that those who perform experiments, create and test hypotheses, and reach reasoned conclusions do so in the full light of day –Without manipulation or ulterior motives. 

Shame on them.

 

Rock River Rimes click here

 

 

 


21
Nov 09

Editorial Cartoon: Marketing fear

The new breast cancer screening results are out.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The news didn’t go over so well. Of course, when you actually listen to what the news is, it doesn’t seem so outrageous. Using fear to market this or that seems to be very popular of late — we need to fear terrorists so please do whatever you feel is needed to protect us. If you smoke you will DIE (real soon), don’t drink or you’ll get wrapped around a tree. For the love of God, don’t have sex and Swine flu will kill you unless you get the vaccine. 

It is true that there are women under fifty who will not get screened (unless they have a known predisposition for breast cancer) and some of them will die. The problem is: many more women will get mastectomies and endure cancer treatment for masses and abnormalities that would not have resulted in death by cancer and, in the absence of detection, may not actually have been a detriment to their health at all.

Fear and emotion are powerful motivators. Knowledge advances over time. By my understanding, the results simply indicate that the overall value of early mammogram and self-exam are eclipsed by the potential harm of false-positive detections. This knowledge only comes with time and reasearch. For otherwise healthy women who do not have risk factors for breast cancer (or cancer in general), the probability of contracting breast cancer is less dangerous than the possibility of false-positives and the treatment that follows. In this litigious society, do you really think a doctor is going to walk into the recovery room after your preventative double mastectomy and tell you that the mass probably wouldn’t have killed you, but it’s better to be "safe than sorry?" What about an informed decision?

The study claims that cost was not considered as criteria, only effectiveness. Just about every time that cost is not considered, the results seem to point to less treatment rather than more. This is a giant red flag telling us that the people who make money from this (and other fear marketing) are more concerned about profit than actual care. I heard a news report on NPR where a woman stated that this was an attack on women. Isn’t it an attack on women to be fearmongered into unnecessary tests that could lead to more unnecessary tests up to chemotherapy and mastectomies? Christina Applegate had a double mastectomy as prevention. In her case, there is a history of cancer in her family, but there is at least anecdotal evidence that other women without risk factors are choosing the same option because it is better to be safe than sorry. The real attack on women is that the organizations who stand to make money money from the detection of, treatment of and the folks who sell pink ribbons have so entrenched themselves in the psyche of American women that they have lost the ability to make an informed decision about their own lives.

Yes, there will be women under the age of fifty who will die from breast cancer. If the new guidelines are implemented, even more may die. That is sad and unfortunate, but the real efforts should be undertaken to find ways to better detect and prevent cancer, not to defend methods and practices that have been shown to be inadequate. In the end, however, this is an opportunity for our wives, daughters, sisters and mothers to stop being a profit center and start being proprietors of their own care?

If you are a woman and you want a mammogram or want to learn how to administer a breast self-exam, then do it. If there’s a fight to be had it is the fight to ensure that the tests remain available and covered by insurance for those who choose to have them. Demand information that will help you come to reasoned and informed conclusion about what’s best for you, and not what’s best for a doctor, clinic, or pink-ribbon pushing activist.

Knowledge is power.

 

P.S. 

I just did some data mining at the National cancer institue web page. According to their own data, at 95% confidence, they report about an eightfold increase in diagnosis/death in women over fifty versus women fourty-nine and younger. For women under fourty-nine, regardless of risk factors, the chance of being diagnosed with breast cancer is around .008%. According to Wikianswers, your 50 year chance of dying an automobile accident is roughly 1%. Perhaps more effort should be spent on protecting women from cars.

Rock River Times Click Here 


18
Nov 09

Editorial Cartoon: Thomson and the Congressman

Never look a gift "permanently detained without a trial" horse in the mouth. . .

 

 

Mr. Manzullo thinks that bringing Gitmo detainees to Illinois is a bad thing — seems like a match made in heaven — After all, this is the state that recently (and during the time that the IOC was debating to allow Chicago to host the Summer Olympics) saw a young man brutally beaten to death by a bunch of red-blooded American kids. I don’t think that even the craziest, most battle-hardened Al Qa’ida member would come to Illinois regardless of the number of virgins he may deflower in the afterlife. Normally, I would support the Congressman as he has been beneficial, but, this time — not so much.

 

Rock River Times click 

here for color, or

here for grayscale

Of course the material on this site is copyright Story, 2009. All rights reserved. 


2
Nov 09

Editorial Cartoon: Legalize pot

 

 

 Rock River Times click here

The content on this site is property of Story, copyright 2009. All rights reserved. 


31
Oct 09

Editorial Cartoon: Economy on life support

 

 

Rock River Times Click here

The images and content on this site are property of Story, copyright 2009. All rights reserved.


29
Oct 09

Editorial cartoon: Death takes a holiday

 

 

Nothing like building fervor for a product and failing to deliver.

Rock River Times click here

 

The images on this site are property of Story. Copyright 2009. All rights reserved.


13
Sep 09

Editorial cartoon: Library closure

Rock River Times Click Here

All images property Story, copyright 2009. All rights reserved. 


13
Sep 09

Editorial cartoon: It’s too late to worry about socialism

 

Republicans complain that health care reform is an entre into socialism — too bad there have been equally socialistic programs in place for years. It seems that the energy spent on hating the president would better be used trying to understand what a strong America really looks like and then trying to help get us there. 

It seems more and more that republicans are their own worst enemies. 

Rock River Times Click Here

 

The images on this site are property of Story, copyright 2009. All rights reserved. 


11
Aug 09

Editorial cartoon: Negative Nancy

Somebody buy this chick an American History book.

 

 

Rock River Times Click Here

 

The images and material on this page are copyright Story 2009. All rights reserved. 


9
Aug 09

Editorial Cartoon: The end of man

What will others think when we’re gone?

 

editorial cartoon

 

Rock River Times click here

The content on this page is copyright 2009 by Story. All rights reserved.